| Name | Year | Position | Hometown / High School | |
| 2019 | ||||
| Second Team | Sakura Bals | Jr. | F | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland HS |
| Molly Vanderhoff | Sr. | D | Sterling Heights, Mich. / Henry Ford II HS | |
| Honorable Mention | Autumn Kloha | Fr. | MF | Freeland, Mich. / Freeland HS |
| 2018 | ||||
| First Team | Valentina Giambanco | Jr. | F | Shelby Township, Mich. / Utica HS |
| Molly Vanderhoff | Jr. | MF | Sterling Heights, Mich. / Henry Ford II HS | |
| Second Team | Jennifer Muana | Jr. | D | Windsor, Ontario / Vincent Massey Secondary |
| Honorable Mention | Lindsay Stroebel | Sr. | MF | Freeland, Mich. / Nouvel CC |
| 2017 | ||||
| First Team | Jennifer Muana | So | D | Windsor, Ontario / Vincent Massey Secondary |
| Molly Vanderhoff | So | F | Sterling Heights, Mich. / Henry Ford II HS | |
| Honorable Mention | Mallory Hestwood | Jr | F | Jackson, Mich. / Lumen Christi HS |
| 2016 | ||||
| Second-Team | Ashley Henderson | Sr. | Midfielder | Southgate, Mich. / Gabriel Richard |
| Bria Spraggins | Sr. | Defender | Grand Rapids, Mich. / Forest Hills Central | |
| Honorable Mention | Jennifer Muanamputu | Fr. | Defender | Windsor, Ontario / Vincent Massey |
| 2015 | ||||
| First-Team | Presley Tibbetts | Sr. | Defender | Grandville, Mich. / Grandville |
| Second-Team | Ashley Henderson | Jr. | Forward | Southgate, Mich. / Gabriel Richard |
| Honorable Mention | Samantha Dunn | Fr. | Defender | Shelby Township, Mich. / Eisenhower |
| 2014 | ||||
| Goalkeeper of the Year | Claire Spleth | So. | Goalkeeper | Indianapolis, Ind. / Youngstown State |
| First-Team | Presley Tibbetts | Jr. | Midfielder | Grandville, Mich. / Grandville |
| Claire Spleth | So. | Goalkeeper | Indianapolis, Ind. / Youngstown State | |
| Second-Team | Ashley Henderson | So. | Midfielder | Southgate, Mich. / Gabriel Richard |
| Shelby Thompson | Sr. | Defender | Midland, Mich. / Dow | |
| Honorable Mention | Shelby Watts | So. | Forward | Waterford, Mich. / Waterford Kettering |
| 2013 | ||||
| Second-Team | Jennifer Goethals | Fr. | Forward | Rochester, Mich. / Rochester |
| Honorable Mention | Presley Tibbetts | So. | Midfielder | Grandville, Mich. / Grandville |
| 2012 | ||||
| First-Team | Charley Porter | Sr. | Defender | Midland, Mich. |
| Honorable Mention | Annie Aubrey | So. | Midfielder | Jackson, Mich. / Jackson |
| 2011 | ||||
| Freshman of the Year | Laura Ivezaj | Fr. | Goalkeeper | Rochester Hills, Mich. / Rochester |
| Second-Team | Abby Bellamy | Sr. | Defender | Davison, Mich. |
| Laura Ivezaj | Fr. | Goalkeeper | Rochester Hills, Mich. / Rochester | |
| 2009 | ||||
| Second-Team | Jaclyn Barrett | Sr. | Forward | Williamston, Mich. |
| Renee Privette | Sr. | Midfielder | Port Huron, Mich. | |
| Abby Ballamy | Fr. | Defender | Davison, Mich. | |
| 2008 | ||||
| First-Team | Stephanie Roy | Sr. | Midfielder | Royal Oak, Mich. / Dondero |
| Second-Team | Kim Oberski | Sr. | Forward | Port Huron, Mich. |
| 2007 | ||||
| Second-Team | Stephanie Roy | Jr. | Midfielder | Royal Oak, Mich. / Dondero |
| Stacy LaLond | Sr. | Goalkeeper | Cheboygan, Mich. | |
| 2006 | ||||
| First-Team | Stephanie Roy | So. | Midfielder | Royal Oak, Mich. / Dondero |
| Second-Team | Kim Oberski | So. | Forward | Port Huron, Mich. |
| Sarah Peters | So. | Defender | Saginaw, Mich. / Heritage | |
| Stacy LaLond | Jr. | Goalkeeper | Cheboygan, Mich. | |
| 2005 | ||||
| First-Team | Stephanie Roy | Fr. | Midfielder | Royal Oak, Mich. / Dondero |
| Second-Team | Stacy LaLond | Jr. | Goalkeeper | Cheboygan, Mich. |
| Kelly Pruitt | Jr. | Forward | Shelby Twp., Mich. / Utica | |
| 2004 | ||||
| First-Team | Jennifer Prior | Sr. | Forward | Flushing, Mich. |
| Ashleigh Burke | Jr., | Midfielder | Saginaw, Mich. / Heritage |