2019

Connor Rutz

United Soccer Coaches All-America Second Team

2018

Omar Sinclair

D2CCA All-American Third Team

2016

Matt Wilson
D2CCA All-American Honorable Mention

2015

Tyler Channell
D2CCA All-American First Team
D2CCA Midwest Region Player of the Year

Jordan Kalk
D2CCA All-American Third Team
GLIAC Freshman of the Year

2014

Craig Neal
NSCAA All-American Third Team
NSCAA Scholar All-American
CoSIDA Academic All-American

2012

Zach Myers
NSCAA & Daktronics, Inc. All-American First Team
NSCAA National "Player of the Year"
CapitalOne Academic All-American

Jason Wise
NSCAA All-American Third Team
First Team All-GLIAC Goalkeeper
Daktronics, Inc. Second Team All-Midwest Region