| Name | Year | Hometown/Previous School | |
| 2018 | |||
| Second Team | Ryan Peruski | Sr. | Saline, Mich. |
| Austin Carter | Sr. | Applegate, Mich. | |
| Honorable Mention | Mason Motte | Sr. | Jeddo, Mich. |
| 2017 | |||
| First-Team | Ryan Peruski | Jr. | Saline, Mich. / Saline |
| Second-Team | Mason Motte | Jr. | Jeddo, Mich. |
| 2016 | |||
| Honorable Mention | Ryan Peruski | So. | Saline, Mich. / Saline |
| 2014-15 | |||
| Second-Team | Micah Skidmore | Sr. | Saginaw, Mich. / Home School |
| 2014 | |||
| First-Team | Micah Skidmore | Jr. | Saginaw, Mich. / Home School |
| Wyatt Drost | Jr. | Charlevoix, Mich. / Charlevoix | |
| 2012 | |||
| First-Team | Micah Skidmore | Fr. | Saginaw, Mich. / Home School |
| Freshman of the Year | Micah Skidmore | Fr. | Saginaw, Mich. / Home School |
| 2011 | |||
| First-Team | Nate Kelly | Sr. | Suttons Bay, Mich. / Suttons Bay |
| Athlete of the Year | Nate Kelly | Sr. | Suttons Bay, Mich. / Suttons Bay |
| 2010 | |||
| Second-Team | Nate Kelly | Sr. | Suttons Bay, Mich. / Suttons Bay |
| Honorable Mention | Dieter Schulz | Sr. | Fort Gratiot, Mich. / Port Huron Northern |
| 2009 | |||
| First-Team | Kasey Hocquard | Sr. | Cheboygan, Mich. / Cheboygan |
| 2008 | |||
| First-Team | Kasey Hocquard | Jr. | Cheboygan, Mich. / Cheboygan |
| Second-Team | Sean Rutherford | Sr. | East Lansing, Mich. / Haslett |
| 2007 | |||
| First-Team | Darren Husse | Sr. | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland |
| Adam Miller | Sr. | Gaylord, Mich. / Gaylord | |
| Second-Team | Mike King | Jr. | Livonia, Mich. / Detroit Catholic Central |
| Honorable Mention | Scott Urquhart | Sr. | Queens Ferry, Scotland |
| 2006 | |||
| Second-Team | Scott Urquhart | Jr. | Queens Ferry, Scotland |
| Honorable Mention | Adam Miller | Jr. | Gaylord, Mich. / Gaylord |
| Mike King | So. | Livonia, Mich. / Detroit Catholic Central | |
| Coach of the Year | Andy Bethune | ||
| 2005 | |||
| Honorable Mention | Sean Rutherford | Sr. | East Lansing, Mich. / Haslett |
| Adam Miller | So. | Gaylord, Mich. / Gaylord | |
| 2004 | |||
| Second-Team | Darren Husse | So. | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland |
| Honorable Mention | Adam Miller | Fr. | Gaylord, Mich. / Gaylord |
| 2003 | |||
| Second-Team | Dave Niewadomski | Jr. | Alanson, Mich. / Littlefield |
| 2001 | |||
| Second-Team | Mike Bromm | Sr. | Howell, Mich. / Howell |